diff --git a/data/ui_scripts/frontend_menus/__init__.lua b/data/ui_scripts/frontend_menus/__init__.lua
index 7ee38ff2..30cba4f5 100644
--- a/data/ui_scripts/frontend_menus/__init__.lua
+++ b/data/ui_scripts/frontend_menus/__init__.lua
@@ -87,7 +87,10 @@ end
 local addCustomButtons = function(controller, menuId, buttonTable, isLeader)
   if menuId == LobbyData.UITargets.UI_MPLOBBYMAIN.id then
     utils.RemoveSpaces(buttonTable)
-    utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.THEATER_MP) - 1)
+    local theaterIndex = utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.THEATER_MP)
+    if theaterIndex ~= nil then
+      utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, theaterIndex - 1)
+    end
   end
 
   if menuId == LobbyData.UITargets.UI_MPLOBBYONLINE.id or menuId == LobbyData.UITargets.UI_ZMLOBBYONLINE.id then
@@ -121,11 +124,14 @@ local addCustomButtons = function(controller, menuId, buttonTable, isLeader)
 
   if menuId == LobbyData.UITargets.UI_ZMLOBBYONLINE.id then
     utils.RemoveButton(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.THEATER_ZM)
-    utils.AddLargeButton(controller, buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.THEATER_ZM, #buttonTable + 1)
+    utils.AddLargeButton(controller, buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.THEATER_ZM)
 
     utils.RemoveSpaces(buttonTable)
     utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.SERVER_BROWSER))
-    utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.ZM_BUBBLEGUM_BUFFS) - 1)
+    local bgbIndex = utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.ZM_BUBBLEGUM_BUFFS)
+    if bgbIndex ~= nil then
+      utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, bgbIndex - 1)
+    end
     utils.AddSpacer(buttonTable, utils.GetButtonIndex(buttonTable, CoD.LobbyButtons.STATS))
   end
 end